Do you use music in your courses? I’ve found time and time again that a little bit of well-placed music can add a surprising amount of polish and – more importantly – set the tone of the overall experience. Music can take a shortcut through people’s logical brains and tap into their emotions in a way that’s uncommon with spoken or written words.
Take this promo I showed as part of the ID Challenge session at DevLearn a few weeks ago. It actually generated applause in the middle of the session, and I guarantee that wasn’t due to its cutting-edge custom photography, innovative special effects, or vibrant color scheme! The impact came from timing the verbal and visual elements to a music track that perfectly captured the mood I wanted to create.
However, if you’ve attempted to use music before, you’ve probably experienced how time-consuming and frustrating it can be to sort through the cheese and find just what you want. Editing can be intimidating if it’s not already in your skill set. Depending on the source, stock music can be expensive and in a climate in which it’s hard to get any purchases approved, it may be viewed as frivolous.
But I’ve found that most of these challenges can be worked around without too much trouble. Here are my top tips for finding and working with stock music.
Show restraint. Is music always a great design decision? Of course not. Don’t add music – especially throughout the whole course – to try to convince learners that they’re having fun when the course itself could put an actuary to sleep. As Tom Kulhmann wrote a couple of years ago, “If the course is boring, adding [background] audio will only make it boring and danceable.” Sound effects bear a mention here, as well… Need I say more than “Remember the early days of PowerPoint”? Let’s not go back there.
But assuming you’ve determined that using some music is a good design decision for your project…
Try stock photo sites you already use. A lot of stock photo sites also have music and sound effects. So if your company already has credits with iStockPhoto, for example, it may be easy to just get music as part of your regular media budget.
Search for concrete terms. It’s extremely difficult for people to communicate about music… even well enough to enter search terms for what they want. This may be due to our general lack of music education, but even some musicians and music writers say that talking and writing about music is like dancing about architecture. So I’ve started searching for nouns – people, places, and things – that evoke the feeling I want, rather than adjectives like happy, sad, or upbeat.
For example, when looking for music for the ID Challenge promo, I knew that I wanted something to make the learners feel like heroes. Searching iStockPhoto for “hero” brought me to a track called Superhero that fit the bill perfectly.
Review a contributor’s whole portfolio. You may do this for stock photos already, but it’s even more relevant for music because you’re probably looking for a certain feel rather than specific content. Another thing you may find in the portfolio is different versions of a piece you’ve already identified, or even segments of a piece that can be spliced together, making the editing part super-easy.
On sites that don’t have the ability to search by contributor, look for a “Find More Like This” link or button.
Make it a minor deal. When searching for music, some sites display the key signature of each piece; some even let you filter by key signature. When I’m perusing a collection and everything sounds too happy and upbeat, I often hone in on the minor pieces – those in G minor, B sharp minor, etc. – for more of an edgy, hip feel.
Book(mark) it. When you find something you like – even if not for your current project – save it in a lightbox, bookmark it, or, even better, clip it with a service like Evernote. Stock music searches are so time-consuming that it’s well worth it to have a good filing system so that you will be able to find good picks again. You can also use tags to keep track of which projects you’ve already used which tracks for.
Look for collections with segments, lengths, or loops. Not parts as in separate tracks for trumpet, cello, and wind chimes, but segments as in intro, verse, bridge, conclusion, loop, stinger, or jingle. I’ve found a few gems over the years on crystalgraphics.com, and almost all of their pieces have multiple segments as well as complete tracks in various lengths. (And though they’re marketed as music for PowerPoint, there’s absolutely nothing about them that make them software-specific.) Premiumbeat.com has loops and lengths as well, and their Corporate collection is one of the best all-around I’ve found for low cheesiness factor.
Going back to the ID Challenge promo example, one of the draws for Superhero was that it had a great variety of versions, lengths, and segments. I spliced a stinger and a loop together to create the finished product.
Don’t sweat the editing. I’m not a professional audio editor, but I don’t need to be to work with stock music. Segments are made specifically to fit together without fine editing. And there’s no need for expensive or complicated software, either; Audacity (open-source and free for Mac, PC, or Linux), Myna (online and free), and GarageBand (comes free with a Mac) are all perfectly sufficient. One tip that I would offer is that if you’re laying an audio track under narration, the audio needs to be way quieter than you think it does to keep from overwhelming the voice!
Free your mind. Another option in low-budget situations is to find free stock music. I’ve been pleasantly surprised by the quality of the offerings on freestockmusic.com, for example, though there are tradeoffs – like a very limited selection and not a lot of segments or lengths to play with. But free stock music may be all you need for a particular project, or it may be a gateway to getting more of a budget for better options in the future. My advice is to be as selective as you would be if you were paying, because there’s plenty of free stuff that’s not worth your time. The Microsoft clipart gallery, for example, has perfectly acceptable sound effects but I’ve never found a use for their music.
Just do it. I’ve never succeeded making the case for a music purchase by presenting an oral or written argument to add music… but I’ve never failed getting a music purchase approved by simply inserting comp audio where I wanted it to go and letting the music speak for itself. Just as it can create a powerful experience for learners, it seems to hold the same sway on stakeholders who hold the purse strings… even ones who want things done as cheaply as possible. And lots of site offer comps for proposal purposes, just like image sites do.
What would you add? I look forward to your thoughts on using – and finding – music for e-learning!